Ideas and judgment
How to use AI without giving up independent thinking
By Julián Medina · Director of SourcingUp and creator of CommerceUp
Use AI to explore alternatives and challenge your reasoning. Keep responsibility for defining the goal, checking the evidence and deciding which consequences you are willing to accept.
Ask for reasoning you can challenge
A confident answer can hide assumptions you never agreed to. Ask for those assumptions to be made explicit, then describe a situation in which the recommendation would stop working. A different budget, deadline or capacity constraint can change which option makes sense.
Look for productive disagreements
Instead of asking only for support for an idea, explore a serious objection and the evidence that would resolve it. Then check the relevant sources. A conversation can broaden your perspective, but generating an argument and verifying it are different tasks. Not every decision needs endless debate; what matters is recognizing which uncertainties affect the choice.
Keep a record of your own reasoning
When you make a decision, write down why you chose it and what would make you reconsider. That record helps you learn from the outcome. I am interested in the meeting point between increasingly capable tools and people who keep asking questions: what we choose to think about, who shapes our attention and how much room we leave for doubt.
Put it into practice
- Explain the objective before asking for alternatives.
- Identify assumptions and pending evidence.
- Explore a relevant objection.
- Record the reason for your decision.
The thinking behind this guide
A guide by Julián Medina. The scenarios are illustrative, not measured customer outcomes. More ideas on Medium.